Misleading ANI, PTI reports omit US state dept's statement on internet shutdown - Alt News
Pooja Chaudhuri
5th February 2021 / 1:50 pm / Last updated: 5th February 2021
The farmers’ protest against Prime Minister Modi’s agricultural law drew international attention after American pop artist Rihanna tweeted in support. Several other global personalities have since extended support to the movement, leading the Indian Ministry of External Affairs to issue a statement and Indian celebrities to tweet in favour of the government’s policy. An overwhelming number of media outlets have also alluded that the international support is a global conspiracy against India.
The latest news widespread across media organisations is that the United States ‘backed’ India’s farm laws. “US backs India’s new farm laws, says these reforms will improve the efficiency of markets,” tweeted ANI on January 4. ANI’s report was carried by Catch News, Business Standard and The Economic Times.
US backs India’s new farm laws, says these reforms will improve efficiency of markets
Read @ANI Story | https://t.co/3ovH5Hf2gO pic.twitter.com/iOzaCzPCEA
— ANI Digital (@ani_digital) February 4, 2021
The Times of India and Times Now republished a similar story by PTI.
US backs India’s new farm laws, says it will improve efficiency of markets https://t.co/4902QKExvz
— TOI India (@TOIIndiaNews) February 4, 2021
Livemint also claimed that the US ‘backed’ farm laws in India.
#FarmersProtest | US backs India’s new farm laws, says peaceful protests hallmark of a democracy
(@ElizaR24 reports) https://t.co/esQbwMnG6J pic.twitter.com/j8q3B48qBz
— Mint (@livemint) February 4, 2021
Among the Hindi media channels that published the same was CNN News18 and Amar Ujala.
#Breaking– अमेरिका ने कृषि सुधार कानून का किया समर्थन, किसानों की फायदा मिलने की बात कही#FarmLaw #US pic.twitter.com/yrPvhCkI5w
— @HindiNews18 (@HindiNews18) February 4, 2021
Right-wing websites Swarajya and OpIndia also carried stories.
Republic Bharat and Dainik Jagran went a step ahead and reported that the US said the farm laws will increase the impact of Indian markets in the world.
The same was later tweeted by BJP Punjab.
News Nation anchor Deepak Chaurasia, ABP News associate editor Ashish Singh and ANI journalist Naveen Kapoor further amplified the claim. Chaurasia’s tweet was the same as Republic Bharat.
While NDTV’s title did not reflect US backing of the laws, the article said, “Indicating that the new Biden administration is supportive of the Indian government’s move to reform the agricultural sector that attracts private investment and greater market access to farmers…”
The report by ANI mentions the following statements by the US State Department:
“We recognize that peaceful protests are a hallmark of any thriving democracy, and note that the Indian Supreme Court has stated the same.”
“We encourage that any differences between the parties be resolved through dialogue. In general, the United States welcomes steps that would improve the efficiency of India’s markets and attract greater private sector investment.”
The third statement in both ANI and PTI report says – “In general, the United States welcomes steps that would improve the efficiency of India’s markets and attract greater private sector investment.”
This does not explicitly refer to the farm laws. Furthermore, both reports published by multiple news outlets failed to highlight other aspects of the US government’s statement, especially internet shutdown.
In response to @WSJ question on India, the US State Department backs “peaceful protests” , criticises internet bans, says it welcomes market reforms. Awaiting @MEAIndia response https://t.co/CPId4OdoVN
— Suhasini Haidar (@suhasinih) February 4, 2021
“We recognise that unhindered access to information, including the internet, is fundamental to the freedom of expression and a hallmark of a thriving democracy,” reads the statement, also reported by Al Jazeera and reiterated by US Embassy spokesperson in Delhi.
US embassy spox in Delhi (in a statement similar to the US State Department) on farmers’ protests:
“We recognize that peaceful protests are a hallmark of any thriving democracy, and note that the Indian Supreme Court has stated the same.”@IndianExpress
— Shubhajit Roy (@ShubhajitRoy) February 4, 2021
News agencies ANI and PTI failed to report the US government’s stance on internet shutdown in India and inferred that the country backed farm laws even as the statement says that the US “in general” supports agricultural reform and has not specifically backed the legislation. It has called for dialogue between parties and commented on internet shutdowns. The response of the Indian Ministry of External Affairs can be read here.
Pooja Chaudhuri is a senior editor at Alt News.
Inter-faith relationships between Hindu women and Muslim men have been a sore point for the…
Right after Elon Musk took over the reins of microblogging site Twitter, the organization carried…
A six-second-long clip of a civilian slapping French President Emmanuel Macron while he is interacting…
Former Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan was allegedly shot at during a rally in Wazirabad…
In a now-deleted article titled “दीप प्रज्ज्वलन के वैज्ञानिक और आध्यात्मिक पक्ष, जानें ये है…