Nine children killed by speeding car. How did media cover Muzaffarpur tragedy? - Alt News
Arjun Sidharth
27th February 2018 / 3:58 pm
Nine children were killed and 24 injured when a speeding vehicle slammed into a school at Muzaffarpur in Bihar on February 24. This shocking incident was the main talking point for political parties, as the accused is alleged to be a BJP worker.
#SpotVisuals: Nine students dead, 24 injured after a vehicle rammed into a school building in #Bihar‘s Muzaffarpur pic.twitter.com/n8E4UNwY8R
— ANI (@ANI) February 24, 2018
Alt News looked at the coverage by television news channels and newspapers for English and Hindi to see whether the issue made it to the prime time slot and the front page. We looked at the prime time coverage for February 24 and February 25. For newspapers, we looked at the Sunday edition i.e. February 25, a day after the incident. Here is what we found.
ENGLISH
TV NEWS CHANNELS
Times Now
For Times Now, the news of the nine slain children was not as important as Mani Shankar Aiyar. The favourite punching bag of mainstream TV news channels was once again on air on Saturday, the day the tragedy occurred.
I’ve known him for 50 years since we were undergraduates. He’s a brilliant person: Sumanth C Raman, Political Analyst from #AiyarSecretMeetTape pic.twitter.com/iMbJg3rN85
— TIMES NOW (@TimesNow) February 24, 2018
#AiyarSecretMeetTape was the hashtag for the show by senior anchor Rahul Shivshankar at 8 pm. The other topic was on the recent bank scam. On Sunday i.e. February 25, a day after the incident, the channel focused on Sridevi. The channel however did cover the news even though it may not have made it to the prime time slot. The focus on the story did not wane the day after and in fact picked up momentum.
53 hours after Muzaffarpur tragic road accident which killed 9 children, Bihar Police is yet to arrest BJP leader Manoj Baitha. @roypranesh speaks with Muzaffarpur SP Vivek Kumar #ArrestHitAndRunBJPNeta pic.twitter.com/B4H2TimSen
— TIMES NOW (@TimesNow) February 26, 2018
Republic TV
For Republic TV, the most important story on February 24 was singer Papon who landed in controversy after a video of him kissing a minor was broadcast. #ArrestPapon was the hashtag for the channel, which also went on to conduct a Twitter poll on the same with the question: Should ‘pervert’ Papon be arrested? Republic TV on February 26 i.e. two days after the incident reported on the FIR filed against the accused BJP leader Manoj Baitha and kept the heat on him.
#BJPNetaHitAndRun | The BJP leader, who is named in the FIR for mowing down 9 children, is abscondinghttps://t.co/Ztxy9O7pA3
— Republic (@republic) February 26, 2018
India Today
India Today did report the story as and when it happened on the 24th, and the channel presented a ground report from Muzaffarpur that detailed the incident.
9 innocent children lost their lives in a tragic accident in Muzaffarpur. Know more about this accident in this report by @rohit_manas.#ReporterDiary
Watch more videos at https://t.co/Nounxo6IKQ pic.twitter.com/NogP1V5Prl
— India Today (@IndiaToday) February 24, 2018
For the prime time slot on Feb 24 and Feb 25, the channel focused on the bilateral relationship between India and Pakistan and Sridevi respectively. Anchor Gaurav Sawant on his show #IndiaFirst conducted a debate on Indo-Pak relations with the question ‘Is it time for India to cut off all sports, cultural connections with Pakistan?’.
Is it time for India to cut off all sports, cultural connections with Pakistan?#IndiaFirst with @gauravcsawant@JaiveerShergill@SudhanshuTrived
Watch full weekend special show https://t.co/JI3pfopiAzpic.twitter.com/UtN9rQfaST
— India Today (@IndiaToday) February 24, 2018
NDTV
NDTV reported the news on the day the incident occurred. The channel kept up its coverage and came out with a series of reports on the tragedy. Overall, the news was given a degree of prominence.
BJP suspends Bihar leader accused of running over 9 children with his SUV https://t.co/ODvykZhOvZ pic.twitter.com/rjEcVsITvY
— NDTV (@ndtv) February 27, 2018
CNN News18
CNN News18 did a ground report on the story wherein its reporter spoke to the families of the slain children. The channel also made it a talking point in its prime time slot with the 10 pm slot on February 26, targeting the Nitish Kumar led state government.
.@BJP4India neta mows down 9 children in Bihar; 24 hours on, ‘killer’ neta still on the run. ‘Sushasan Babu’ @nitishkumar‘s ‘political duplicity’ exposed. Watch #Epicentre with @maryashakil at 10pm; tweet using #BJPKillerNeta pic.twitter.com/ICWuPRinlf
— News18 (@CNNnews18) February 26, 2018
NEWSPAPERS
Newspapers were no different when it came to determining the degree of prominence to be given to this news. We looked at the front pages of leading newspapers (Delhi edition) and here is what we found:
Times of India
On February 25, Times of India on its front page made no mention of this news.
The report was hidden in the inner pages of the daily. On Page 10, the story was mentioned in a tiny column. There was no reference to the accused being a BJP leader.
Hindustan Times
The report was the top most story for Hindustan Times, which covered it prominently on its front page in its February 25 edition. It did not however mention the accused’s link with the BJP.
Indian Express
Indian Express which is known to give attention to human interest stories too failed to print this news on its front page of Sunday Express.
Instead, in a manner similar to Times of India, the newspaper published this report on Page 9. However, it gave more importance to the story than ToI did, giving it more space although there was no reference to the political links of the accused.
DNA
Daily News and Analysis (DNA), another prominent English language daily carried the news on the front page in the bottom right corner on February 25.
HINDI
TV NEWS CHANNELS
Zee News
Zee News, one of the most news channels reported the news from Muzaffarpur on February 24. It reported ‘BJP leader’s car hits crowd in Bihar, 9 children killed, many injured’.
BJP leader’s car hits crowd in Bihar; 9 children killed, many injuredhttps://t.co/6h8jggzOQd pic.twitter.com/6YDM4fHuqO
— Zee News (@ZeeNews) February 24, 2018
The focus of prime time though was on other stories. Anchor Sudhir Chaudhary discussed how private hospitals fleece patients.
#DNAWeekendEdition: प्राइवेट अस्पतालों की लूट के खुलासे का #DNA टेस्ट रात 9 बजे @ZeeNews पर @sudhirchaudhary के साथ pic.twitter.com/CcPisXpfPY
— Zee News Hindi (@ZeeNewsHindi) February 24, 2018
On Sunday, i.e February 25, Sridevi was expectedly in the prime time show. The channel also discussed the Sangh Parivar’s plans to help PM Modi emerge victorious in 2019.
संघ का ‘सुपर शो’ बनाएगा बीजेपी को ‘शक्तिमान’
संघ के मंथन से मोदी जीतेंगे 2019!
9:10 PM @ZeeNewspic.twitter.com/w4k713oyiQ
— Zee News Hindi (@ZeeNewsHindi) February 25, 2018
Aaj Tak
Another popular channel Aaj Tak focused on the tussle in Delhi between the State Govt and the Centre on the day the tragedy occurred.
पहले थप्पड़ कांड, अब कटोरा राग! (@AajGothi , @manideep_shrma, @PankajJainClick )
देखिए #India360: https://t.co/0vgbDcivG9 pic.twitter.com/cNLyggU5wq
— आज तक (@aajtak) February 24, 2018
The next day on February 25, the channel presented a ground report from Muzaffarpur on the tragedy.
बीजेपी नेता की गाड़ी से मुजफ्फरपुर में हुई दुर्घटना में 10 बच्चों की मौत के बाद अब ये बात सामने आ रही है कि गाड़ी खुद महादलित मंच के प्रदेश मंत्री मनोज बैठा चला रहे थे।
सुजीत झा की रिपोर्ट #ReporterDiary pic.twitter.com/HUzik3D3oQ
— आज तक (@aajtak) February 25, 2018
India TV
India TV, the Rajat Sharma owned channel broke the news from Muzaffarpur in the afternoon of February 24, soon after the incident. Apart from this, there was very little coverage of this news on the channel.
#BreakingNews: 9 students killed, 24 injured after vehicle rams into school building in #Bihar https://t.co/Su1cYaaguQ
— India TV (@indiatvnews) February 24, 2018
For prime time, the channel broadcasted reports on Nirav Modi and Virat Kohli. The next day’s coverage was dedicated to Sridevi.
Watch our Special Show on #TeamIndia captain @imVkohli Tonight at 9 @indiatvnewspic.twitter.com/PgEGywKYew
— Rajat Sharma (@RajatSharmaLive) February 24, 2018
NEWSPAPERS
Dainik Jagran
One of the most widely read Hindi dailies Dainik Jagran in its Sunday edition on February 25 had Nirav Modi as its lead story. The report was about how the Govt is acting tough and a chargesheet is soon to be filed in a month. There was no mention of Muzaffarpur and the slain school children on the front page.
Amar Ujala
Amar Ujala, a widely read newspaper did justice to the tragic news from Bihar and carried it on the front page.
Hindustan
Hindustan carried this story on the front page right at the top, in its edition of February 25.
Navbharat Times
Navbharat Times which is owned by the Times of India group did not feature the news on the front page. Instead, it carried it on page 3 albeit in a tiny column as a snippet under the ‘Fast News’ section.
While TV news channels did report the story from Muzaffarpur as and when it occurred, and some channels also did ground reports, the prime time slots on the weekend were dedicated to other stories, with Sridevi dominating viewer space. The story received more coverage from February 26, two days later. Moreover, we found that as news of the accused’s political links became clear, all news channels mentioned this aspect, whereas in the case of newspapers on February 25 i.e. a day after the incident, this reference was missing. Insofar as newspapers are concerned, some gave the tragedy diminutive importance while others featured it prominently.
Arjun Sidharth is a writer with Alt News. He has previously worked in the television news industry, where he managed news bulletins and breaking news scenarios, apart from scripting numerous prime time television stories. He has also been actively involved with various freelance projects. Sidharth has studied economics, political science, international relations and journalism. He has a keen interest in books, movies, music, sports, politics, foreign policy, history and economics. His hobbies include reading, watching movies and indoor gaming.
Rahul and Priyanka Gandhi recently performed aarti at the Narmada Ghat in Madhya Pradesh’s Omkareshwar…
In the wake of the alleged murder of Shraddha Walkar by his partner Aftab Amin…
The video of a group of people stopping an e-rickshaw with BJP flags attached to…
Last week during the G20 summit in Bali, world leaders were informed of a missile…
Recently, several prominent BJP leaders claimed that Prime Minister Narendra Modi had intervened to stop…