Old images of mazar demolished in UP in 2018 shared as recent - Alt News
Nilofar Absar
18th April 2022 / 4:37 pm
Photos of a Muslim shrine or mazar being demolished with a JCB machine have been shared with the claim that the structure was illegal and it was torn down in Uttar Pradesh’s Govardhan Parikrama Marg. BJYM UP social media head Richa Rajpoot shared the images hailing UP chief minister Yogi Adityanath.
गोवर्धन परिक्रिमा मार्ग में अवैध रूप से अतिक्रमण कर बनी मजारो पर J C B चला कर साफ किया जा रहा है, यह काम करने की क्षमता केवल योगी बाबा में ही है !! pic.twitter.com/NLO1FmD3lM
— Dr. Richa Rajpoot (@doctorrichabjp) April 4, 2022
It is noteworthy that these images are being shared against the backdrop of Ram Navami violence reported in several states. There were videos of a mazar being demolished in Haryana and state governments in Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat razing down houses of people accused of being involved in the violence.
The images were also shared by BJP supporters on Twitter.
गोवर्धन परिक्रिमा मार्ग में अवैध रूप से अतिक्रमण कर बनी मजारो पर बुलडोजर चला कर साफ किया जा रहा है, यह काम करने की क्षमता केवल योगी बाबा में ही है!!#योगी बाबा जिंदाबाद!! 🙏🏾
ये है आपके एक वोट की ताकत 🙏🏾 pic.twitter.com/SIzOeuasVF
— Eagle Eye (@SortedEagle) April 6, 2022
मथुरा के #गोवर्धन परिक्रिमा मार्ग में अवैध रूप से अतिक्रमण कर बनी मजारो पर J C B चला कर साफ किया जा रहा है, यह काम करने की क्षमता केवल योगी बाबा में ही है💪 pic.twitter.com/1swvG1HrYT
— Sintu Tiwari🇮🇳 💯🚩% FB (@Tiwari_Sintu999) November 16, 2020
They are widespread on Facebook with the identical claim that an illegally constructed mazar was demolished by CM Adityanath in Govardhan Parikrama Marg.
We first performed reverse image searches on Google and Yandex and found tweets dating back to 2020 carrying the same images and claim.
@myogiadityanath @ptshrikant
गोवर्धन परिक्रिमा मार्ग में अवैध रूप से अतिक्रमण कर बनी मजारो पर JCB चला कर साफ किया जा रहा है, यह काम करने की क्षमता केवल योगी बाबा में ही है.
वरना खुद को यदुवंशी @yadavakhilesh ने तो हर जगह मजार ही मजार बना डाली।
🤩🤩 pic.twitter.com/NJpdjO4U3M
— विनीत भारतीय (@Vinit_singhal) November 17, 2020
We then performed a keyword search on Google and found a report by The Times of India dating back to October 2018 reporting on the removal of “encroachments” including temples from Giriraj Parvat and Govardhan Parikrama areas of Mathura district, pursuant to an order by the National Green Tribunal. Interestingly, the TOI article mentions that “the order further stated that no “samadhi” (grave) falling in the existing land is to be removed”.
We also found a video report by Neo News covering the demolition of mazars in Govardhan Parikrama area.
[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N4LPe2sqdb8]
It is pertinent to highlight that the video report states that pursuant to the NGT order, the PWD had also carried out the demolition of around five temples of varying sizes in the same area.
Keeping the time frame of these reports in mind, we performed a keyword search on Twitter using advanced search filters and found tweets with the same viral images dating back to November 2018.
गोवर्धन परिक्रमा मार्ग में बनी सभी मज़ारों को आज ध्वस्त कर दिया है कहीं कोई ढोंग ढकोसला नहीं हुआ !(न कोई पीर निकला कोई न फकीर) pic.twitter.com/9Bpfp4nZfe
— Harshit Tripathi (@Harsh7tripathi) November 16, 2018
Thus, the images are four years old.
Nilofar Absar is a lawyer by training and a storyteller by nature who takes a keen interest in the lives of people belonging to South Asian diasporic communities.
In the wake of the alleged murder of Shraddha Walkar by his partner Aftab Amin…
The CCTV footage of a man violently flinging a child on the ground has created…
A minute-long video clip of a woman being physically assaulted is viral on social media….
Trigger Warning: The following story contains graphic imagery. Several users have shared images of the…
The brutal murder of Shraddha Walker has been widely covered across news media over the…