Smriti's Irani's "blood-soaked sanitary napkin" remark - did the minister fall for social media hoax? - Alt News
Pooja Chaudhuri
24th October 2018 / 7:40 pm
In the wake of the Sabarimala row, Union Textiles Minister Smriti Irani stirred up a controversy with her remark on menstruating women entering temples. “I am nobody to speak on the Supreme Court verdict because I am a current serving Cabinet Minister. But just plain common sense. Would you take sanitary napkins steeped in menstrual blood and walk into a friend’s home? You will not. And do you think that it is respectful to do the same when you walk into the house of God? So that is the difference. I have a right to pray. I do not have the right to desecrate. That is my personal opinion,” she said in Young Thinkers’ Conference organised by ORF on October 23.
We are in conversation with Union Minister of textiles,Smt Smriti Irani; Moderated by Mr Samir Saran, President, Observer Research Foundation at the #YTC2018
Posted by ORF Mumbai on Monday, 22 October 2018
Soon after, social media was brimming with those criticising Irani’s remarks, which she claimed was “fake news”.
Fake news …… calling you out on it. Will post my video soon. https://t.co/ZZzJ26KBXa
— Smriti Z Irani (@smritiirani) October 23, 2018
Subsequently, several journalists pointed out to Irani that it was she who had fallen for fake news as no reports suggest that women entered Sabarimala with blood-soaked sanitary pads.
Dear Ms Irani, it’s you who seems to be falling for fake news. Can you point at one credible news source that says women wanted to take sanitary pads, blood-soaked or unused, to #Sabarimala? Where is this suggestion coming from? https://t.co/1LIsb9YupG
— Manisha Pande (@MnshaP) October 23, 2018
BJP MP Smriti Irani’s remark seemed to be the outcome of a rumour which claimed that activist Rehana Fatima carried a blood-soaked sanitary napkin in her ‘Irumudikkettu’ (a prayer offering to God) to Sabarimala.
Pro-BJP Kerala media outlet Janam TV gave birth to the grapevine, according to Newslaundry. In an article published on October 19, Janam TV made the aforestated claim which was subsequently viral on social media (1, 2, 3, 4).
However, as with most rumours, its original version changed with progression. Subsequent to Irani’s remark, several right-wing Twitter handles came to the Union Minister’s defence and alleged that Fatima carried a soiled pad on her head.
Fatima Rehana was allegedly carrying a blood stained sanitary pad on her head.
Is that where women menstruate from? From the head?
Would u go visit your God (Kejri) with a blood stained pad on your head? https://t.co/4BLgYZ8xai
— Eminent Intellectual (@padhalikha) October 23, 2018
But Irani, in her clarification, seemed to suggest that she hadn’t fallen for misinformation. The minister tweeted that she was “yet to find a person who ‘takes’ a blood-soaked napkin to ‘offer’ to anyone let alone a friend.”
As far as those who jump the gun regarding women visiting friend’s place with a sanitary napkin dipped in menstrual blood — I am yet to find a person who ‘takes’ a blood soaked napkin to ‘offer’ to any one let alone a friend.
— Smriti Z Irani (@smritiirani) October 23, 2018
Then why exactly did the Union Textile Minister make the remark in the first place at the youth conference?
There is no reasonable explanation for Smriti Irani’s statement about blood-soaked sanitary napkins apart from the reference to the alleged incident involving Rehana Fatima. Moreover, there are no reported cases of women ever carrying soiled pads to temples, or anywhere else for that matter.
When Alt News contacted Rehana Fatima, she brushed off the rumours as “fake news” and added that she wasn’t visiting Sabarimala to protest, but to pray. We also contacted Kerala police for confirmation and they denied that any activist or woman carried a sanitary pad – used or unused – inside the temple.
The BJP MP seemed to imply in her tweet that she hadn’t fallen for misinformation but her rhetorical clarification did little to exonerate her as there is no justification for merely mentioning that women might carry blood-soaked pads inside temples.
Moreover, Irani’s other statements were also an attempt to rationalise the religious impositions on women by drawing parallels with Zoroastrianism, which also disallows menstruating women from entering a fire temple. This further hinted at the Union Minister’s stand against the entry of menstruating women in places of worship.
I respect that stand by the Zoroastrian community / priests and do not approach any court for a right to pray as a mother of 2 Zoroastrian children. Similarly Parsi or non Parsi menstruating women irrespective of age DO NOT go to a Fire Temple.
— Smriti Z Irani (@smritiirani) October 23, 2018
After The Wire’s Siddharth Varadarajan tweeted about Smriti’s Irani’s remark, Aaj Tak’s Executive Director Sweta Singh came to her defence and tweeted that “even in the Vatican mini-skirts are not allowed”. When Varadarajan pointed out that soiled sanitary napkins are thrown out by women and not carried on ‘tours’, Singh remarked that if Varadarajan was unaware of the ‘tour’ Smriti Irani was referring to, he should have refrained from commenting on the subject. Singh, however, failed to mention the ‘tour’ she was talking about.
माफ़ करिए मुझे नहीं मालूम था आपको सैनिटरी पैड पहनने का अधिक अनुभव है। पर आगे से इस्तेमाल किए पैड फेंक दीजिएगा। और अगर आपने नहीं सुना कि ‘इस्तेमाल किया पैड’ किस ‘tour’ पे ले जाया गया तो @smritiirani के बयान पे टिप्पणी क्यों की? हद से ज़्यादा मासूम निकले आप तो। https://t.co/OPZyb1Bby3
— Sweta Singh (@SwetaSinghAT) October 24, 2018
Despite police statements clarifying that no such incident of carrying sanitary pads – used or unused – took place, the Executive Director of one of the most popular news organisations seemed to have fallen for the same misinformation as Smriti Irani.
The Prime Minister’s Union Cabinet has 26 ministers, out of which only four are women. As one among this meagre number, Smriti Irani’s recent statements set a dangerous precedent as her views may be seen as a barometer to the government’s approach toward women’s issues. She not only seemingly fell for a social media rumour but used the misinformation to further her stand against the entry of menstruating women in Sabarimala.
Pooja Chaudhuri is a senior editor at Alt News.
Rahul and Priyanka Gandhi recently performed aarti at the Narmada Ghat in Madhya Pradesh’s Omkareshwar…
In the wake of the alleged murder of Shraddha Walkar by his partner Aftab Amin…
The video of a group of people stopping an e-rickshaw with BJP flags attached to…
Last week during the G20 summit in Bali, world leaders were informed of a missile…
Recently, several prominent BJP leaders claimed that Prime Minister Narendra Modi had intervened to stop…