Video of Zaid Hamid's hate speech is from 2013, not after Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan - Alt News
Pooja Chaudhuri
17th August 2021 / 6:23 pm / Last updated: 17th August 2021
A video of Pakistani commentator Zaid Hamid’s remarks during an ARY News broadcast has surfaced on social media after the Taliban took over Afghanistan. He can be heard saying, “Danish, if you truly ask me, I pray to Allah that the Americans withdraw from [Afghanistan], and leave the Indians there; it has been a long time since we massacred Hindus in Afghanistan. Historically, it was always like that, and that is why the mountains in Afghanistan are called ‘Hindu Kush.’ ‘Hindu Kush’ means a place where Hindus are to be beheaded, a place that kills Hindus. Historically, whenever Hindus entered Afghanistan, they were butchered there. We pray to Allah that the US withdraws from Afghanistan, and leaves the Bania [Hindu community of merchants] in their place. The things we would do to the Bania in Afghanistan would make them refrain from looking toward Afghanistan and Pakistan for thousands of years.”
Twitter handle @pakistan_untold tweeted the video claiming it showed Pakistan’s plans for Hindus after the US withdrawal from Afghanistan.
Pakistan’s plans for Hindus after US withdrawal from Afganistan. Live on Pak TV.
(ARY is 2nd largest News agency of Pak. ARY was also the official partner/distributer of Aamir Khan’s blockbuster movie PK in Pak)pic.twitter.com/JiYM9YgHdF
— Pakistan Untold (@pakistan_untold) August 15, 2021
TV9 Bharatvarsh news anchor Shubankar Mishra shared the video with the exact text. He did not specify the date of the ARY News broadcast.
Pakistan’s plans for Hindus after US withdrawal from Afganistan: Zaid Hamid
Live on Pak TV.
(ARY is 2nd largest News agency of Pak. ARY was also the official partner/distributer of Aamir Khan’s blockbuster movie PK in Pak)#Pakistan #Afhganistan #hindu
pic.twitter.com/geByzJyPI7
— शुभांकर मिश्रा (@shubhankrmishra) August 17, 2021
The video is widespread on Twitter and Facebook alike.
Alt News has also received verification requests for the video on its WhatsApp helpline number (76000 11160) and mobile application.
Media outlet Newstracklive has penned an article on the video without verifying the date of the broadcast.
Incidentally, Twitter handle @pakistan_untold had also shared the video last year. This itself proves that Zaid Hamid did not make the statements after the Taliban’s takeover of Afghanistan.
“We have not slaughtered Hindus for quite some time. Let’s do it now in Afghanistan.”
Panelist on Pak TV ARY (same group with whom Aamir Khan launched his movie PK in Pakistan). Accompanied by Pak Air Vice Marshal.
Islamophobia is on the rise in Moodi’s India. pic.twitter.com/JiYM9Yyi5d
— Pakistan Untold (@pakistan_untold) December 15, 2020
A keyword search took us to links from December 14, 2013 that shared the video. However, the video has been taken down from YouTube for violating the platform’s rules on hate speech.
However, we did find a copy of the video [a section of Pakistan-based ARY News broadcast] uploaded in 2014.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CT30KDfDD9A
Transcription of the complete statement given by Hamid was found on the website mimri.org. The excerpt in the first paragraph of this fact-check report has been taken from this website. The transcription was published in 2014. The website says that the broadcast dates back to August 11, 2013. Zaid Hamid spoke about how Pakistan should treat India’s presence in Afghanistan after the US troop withdrawal planned by the end of 2014.
Former US president Barack Obama had ordered the US military to make plans to fully pull out American troops from Afghanistan by 2014. Obama’s plan was subsequently withdrawn but the number of troops was reduced. It was further truncated by the next president Donald Trump. Last year, before Trump was voted out, the US signed a deal with the Taliban which said that the US would withdraw all troops within 14 months if the Taliban does not allow Al-Qaeda or any other extremist group to operate in areas under the Taliban’s control. The complete withdrawal of US troops finally took place during the first presidential term of Joe Biden.
Now coming back to Zaid Hamid’s speech. While the Pakistani commentator’s remarks were not recent, Hamid is routinely criticised for xenophobia and hate speech against non-Muslim faiths. He has taken an anti-India stand several times in the past and his Twitter account is also withheld in the country. Hamid had claimed that the 2001 Parliamentary attack convict Ajmal Kasab was an Indian Hindu. (Note: For those who wish to see the hyperlinked tweet, use Tor browser). Hamid is known to spew vitriol against the Hindu community through hate speech and disinformation. Alt News has penned several articles on him before his account was withheld.
Several Pakistanis had condemned Hamid’s statements back in 2013.
Zaid Hamid wants America to leave Afghanistan, so that all Indian Hindus in Afghanistan can be massacre. Why is he allowed on air?
— Sadaf Khan (@nuqsh) August 11, 2013
Zaid Hamid is on crack? Hindus temporarily in the land? People still talk like this? So disrespectful
— Mahim Maher (@MahimMaher) August 11, 2013
A provocative speech against Hindus by Zaid Hamid in 2013 has been shared against the backdrop of the Taliban’s takeover of Afghanistan.
Pooja Chaudhuri is a senior editor at Alt News.
Rahul and Priyanka Gandhi recently performed aarti at the Narmada Ghat in Madhya Pradesh’s Omkareshwar…
In the wake of the alleged murder of Shraddha Walkar by his partner Aftab Amin…
The video of a group of people stopping an e-rickshaw with BJP flags attached to…
Last week during the G20 summit in Bali, world leaders were informed of a missile…
Recently, several prominent BJP leaders claimed that Prime Minister Narendra Modi had intervened to stop…