Far-right columnist Madhu Kishwar shared an image of a man surrounded by children. According to the text attached to the photograph, he is a Rohingya Muslim who has no food to eat or clothes to wear but has three wives and eight children. It further claims that the man also has a mobile phone worth Rs 29,000.
A Facebook user Neha Patel, who is followed by 28,000 people on the social networking platform, had posted the same image three years ago. Patel’s post was shared 1,700 times.
The complete text read, “दिल्ली में रोड के किनारे रहने वाला एक लाचार असहाय बेसहारा गरीब #रोहिंग्या जिसके पास खाने और पहनने तक को कुछ नहीं है.बस तीन बीबियां जिसमें दो गर्भवती हैं 8 बच्चे हैं और एक सस्ता सा घटिया वाला सैमसंग 7 C7 pro मोबाइल है जिसकी कीमत मात्र 29000 रुपये है…..हमे इनका जीवनस्तर सुधारना है इसलिए समय पर टैक्स दीजिये… #चुप_रहिए_देश_में_सेक्युलरिज़्म_है” (A helpless poor person on the side a road in Delhi. #Rohigya who has no food to eat and no clothes to wear but has three wives, among whom two are pregnant. He has eight children and just a cheap Samsung C7 pro worth Rs 29,000…we want to improve his standard of living so please file your taxes on time. #Shut_up_there_are_seculars_in_the_country)”
On December 14, 2019, Twitter user Dhanesh Agarwal posted the same photograph of man surrounded by children along with a mug shot of another man. The second man has been claimed to be a Rohingya Muslim named Nassir Hussain, who has “3 pregnant wives and 10 children”.
We found the infographic shared by Madhu Kishwar has been circulating at least since 2019.
On Twitter, one Meera Singh (@meeraremi11), who is followed by the office of union ministers Piyush Goyal and Nirmala Sitharaman, had also circulated the post in 2019. (archive).
दिल्ली में रोड के किनारे रहने वाला एक लाचार, बेसहारा गरीब #रोहिंग्या मुसलमान जिसके पास खाने-पहनने तक को नहीं है पर तीन बीबियां जिसमें दो गर्भवती और 8 बच्चे हैं! एक सस्ता वाला सैमसंग7C7pro फोन है जिसकी कीमत मात्र 29हज़ार रु है.
हमे इनका जीवन सुधारना है इसलिए समय पर टैक्स दीजिये pic.twitter.com/VytW2GFXp9— Meera Singh (@meeraremi11) June 15, 2019
Fact-check
Reverse-searching the image on Google led us to an April 15, 2018 ground report by News18, which is titled, “Rohingya Lose Their Sanctuary in Delhi to Fire, New Life of Six Years Turns to Ashes.” The image was credited to photographer Debayan Roy.
According to the report, Rohingya man Haroon had fled persecution in Myanmar. His family, and 52 other Rohingya families, had been living in a makeshift camp Darul Hijrat in Delhi’s Madanpur Khadar since 2012. On April 15, 2018, the camp was engulfed in fire and reduced to ashes. “…the police have ruled out any foul play after teams from the Forensic Sciences Laboratory, BSES Ltd, and the fire department pointed towards a short circuit as the cause of [the] fire,” said the report.
It is to be noted that the News18 report mentions that the residents of the camp were looking for their UN identity card in the rubble. It also adds police’s assurances of rebuilding the asylum and providing fresh IDs hence, the immigrants were not illegal refugees.
Alt News spoke with Roy, who said, “There was a fire in an asylum Darul Hijrat, which is run by Zakat foundation for Rohingya refugees. This place was found mysteriously burnt one morning. The entire area was completely burnt down. These people [in the picture] were sitting in a corner and the man was basically a father of two. His wife and son were hurt in the fire. The phone that you see in his hand was given to him by the Trust when they were serving food. In fact, he looked at the phone like an alien object. Whatever is claimed on social media is not true. This is a really sad turn of events.”
The incident was reported by several media outlets, including BBC‘s ground report, which quotes DCP Southeast Chinmay Biswal as saying, “Cases of negligence have been registered under the related sections. FSL team and the electricity department have investigated the area. The fire department will also submit its report on the cause of the fire. All aspects would be considered to look into the matter.”
A video of The Wire’s ground report is given below.
Image of Rohingya refugee in Bangladesh
By reverse searching the second man’s image on Google, Alt News found the original image clicked by Hafiz Johari, a photographer from Malaysia. “TEKNAF, BANGLADESH – APRIL 1, 2017 : Men face rohingya refugees in refugee camps Leda, Bangladesh,” reads the title given to this Shutter Stock photo. In the comparison below, you can see the cropped-out (mug-shot) image juxtaposed with the original photograph.
Another unrelated story was picked up on social media to target Rohingyas. A photo of a young girl featured in a 2017 BBC documentary was shared with a false and communal spin.
Independent journalism that speaks truth to power and is free of corporate and political control is possible only when people start contributing towards the same. Please consider donating towards this endeavour to fight fake news and misinformation.
