While browsing through Facebook, Alt News recently came across a post on a page named Levi Ponce containing a link to an interview featuring Aaj Tak journalist Shweta Singh. The post caught our attention due to the title, which read, “A confession that surprised everyone!”. It also contained a preview card to a BBC article in which Singh was quoted as saying that she was ashamed of what she had done.
The headline and preview card of this post were so sensational that it prompted us to click on it. Upon opening the link, we were redirected not to the BBC’s website but to a website named thirdlasagna.com which did not have any interviews. We found that the domain redirected to a crypto scam website. (Archived link)
Alt News started looking into the page, and in its Transparency section, we discovered it had been continuously running advertisements. When we opened the Ad Library report of the page, we noticed that this page had run numerous such ads on Facebook, Instagram, Audience Network and Messenger, all containing the same format. In these advertisements, a link is promoted using the image of a public figure or personality and names of international media outlets. This page has run several advertisements using Shweta Singh’s name and picture, screenshots of which are given below. Some of these advertisements have now been deleted, but we have stored their offline versions in a file above the sheets in this article, which readers can download and view.
In the Ad Library of the same page, we found an advertisement featuring images of senior Indian journalist Karan Thapar and Congress MP Shashi Tharoor. This ad, too, promoted a website (thirdlasagna.com) which redirected to a crypto scam domain. One such advertisement featured Karan Thapar’s image, but Shweta Singh was referenced in the text, wherein BBC quoted her as saying that she was ashamed of what she did. (Archived link)
Upon further investigation, Alt News also came across a number of other Facebook pages running such advertisements on both Facebook and Instagram. Some of these are:
- Levi Ponce
- HopeNuggets
- Lazaris TheTopDon
- Loriana Lana
- Sam White
- Quickmart Kenya
- Dytrc
- Baatarbileg Yo
- Houston Christian University
- Amaury et Quentin
It is worth noting that these pages used the same format to promote bizarre links using the names of public personalities and international media outlets, including Indian journalists Karan Thapar and Shweta Singh. The ads also used the same sensationalist headlines and link previews, quoting journalists and several other celebrities, claiming that they were ashamed of their actions. The names of BBC.com and BBC.in were used in these advertisements. Some screenshots have been given below for readers to refer to.
Ratan Tata and Kriti Sanon Victims of Fake Ads
The pages ran advertisements targeting Indian industrialist Ratan Tata and actress Kriti Sanon. A Facebook page named Dytrc shared an edited photo of Ratan Tata and ran an advertisement with it containing a false claim regarding a technical glitch which could change the income of Indians. The preview link mentions that officials tried to interrupt this interview, but it was too late as he had already spoken about it. The other featured a photo of actress Kriti Sanon. The ad read, “Koffee with Karan host Karan Johar called Kriti Sanon ‘irresponsible’ and said on air that ‘financial information of this magnitude can shake the foundation of Indian society.’”
Names of International Media Outlets and Celebrities Misused
Apart from Indian journalists, industrialists, actresses and leaders, names of other celebrities and many international media outlets have been used in the advertisements by these Facebook pages, which include journalists, sports persons, politicians, and other public figures from a variety of countries including India. All the information about advertisements is given in the sheets below. Some of these advertisements have now been removed, so we have stored the offline versions of these advertisements. (All the files related to this sheet can be downloaded by clicking on this link.)
Page | Target/Person (Name/Image) | Profession | Country | Display link | Website URL |
Levi Ponce | Karan Thapar | Journalist | India | BBC.COM | elegantsubmarine.com |
Levi Ponce | Sweta Singh | Journalist | India | BBC.COM | thirdlasagna.com |
Levi Ponce | Ella Kanninen | Journalist | Finland | HS.FI | regularberet.com |
Levi Ponce | Rafał Brzozowski | Singer and TV Presenter | Poland | GAZETA.PL | carefuljail.com |
Levi Ponce | Natalia Willy Druyts | Singer | Belgium | HLN.BE | neatjellyfish.com |
Levi Ponce | Chris Kenny | Politician | Australia | tugboat.splendidroast.com | splendidroast.com |
Levi Ponce | Sandrine Dans | TV Presenter | Belgium | RTBF.BE | loudbath.com |
HopeNuggets | Karan Thapar | Journalist | India | BBC.IN | verdantcardboard.com |
HopeNuggets | Australian Residents | Australia | 9news.com.au | importantpot.com | |
HopeNuggets | Emma Willis | British Broadcaster | UK | BBC.CO.UK | succinctcactus.com |
HopeNuggets | Karl Nehammr | Austrian Chancellor | Austria | OMV.COM | adamantpotato.com |
HopeNuggets | Anthony Norman Albanese | Prime Minister | Australia | ABC.NET.AU | caringstraw.com |
HopeNuggets | Edward Boyd | Business Reporter/Presenter | Austalia | ABC.NET.AU | stripeddictionary.com |
HopeNuggets | Australian Union | Australia | ABC.NET.AU | stripeddictionary.com | |
HopeNuggets | Mike Henry | CEO of BHP | Australia | ABC.NET.AU | stripeddictionary.com |
HopeNuggets | British Citizen | UK | BBC.CO.UK | remarkablecement.com | |
HopeNuggets | Martin Pibworth | MD of Scottish and southern energy | UK | BBC.CO.UK | remarkablecement.com |
HopeNuggets | Anne Glad | Lifestyle Expert | Denmark | BT.DK | miniaturesack.com |
HopeNuggets | Emma Willis | British Broadcaster | UK | malesoybean.com | malesoybean.com |
HopeNuggets | Paz Padilla | Comedian | Spain | ELTIEMPO.ES | calmmechanic.com |
HopeNuggets | Sam Kerr | Soccer Player | Australia | 9NEWS.AU.COM | FARTRUNK.COM |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Karan Thapar | Journalist | India | BBC.COM | elegantsubmarine.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Ella Kanninen | Journalist | Finland | HS.FI | regularberet.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Austalian Residents | Australia | ABC.NET.AU | assortedwax.com | |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Austalian Residents | Australia | OE24.AT | thirdharmonica.com | |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Karl Nehammr | Austrian Chancellor | Austria | OE24.AT | thirdharmonica.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Rafał Brzozowski | Singer and TV Presenter | Poland | GAZETA.PL | roundbooklet.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Sigrid Kaag | Deputy Prime Minster | Netherlands | AD.NL | succinctmonkey.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Mark Rutte | Prime Minister | Netherlands | AD.NL | succinctmonkey.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Jens Stoltenberg | Secretary General Of NATO | Norway | AD.NL | succinctmonkey.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Geert Wilders | Politician | Netherlands | AD.NL | succinctmonkey.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Francine Lacqua | Journalist | Italy | AD.NL | succinctmonkey.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Natalia Willy Druyts | Singer | Belgium | neatjellyfish.com | neatjellyfish.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Sandrine Dans | TV Presenter | Belgium | loudbath.com | loudbath.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Anne Glad | Lifestyle Expert | Denmark | TV2.DK | gulliblebangle.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Andor eva | TV Presenter | Hungary | BLIKK.HU | brainyframe.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Maria Veitola | Journalist | Finland | regularberet.com | regularberet.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Lucie Bila | Singer and Actress | Czech Republic | thinkablecoal.com | thinkablecoal.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Rafał Brzozowski | Singer and TV Presenter | Poland | roundbooklet.com | roundbooklet.com |
Lazaris TheTopDon | Manuel Luís Goucha | Journalist | Portugal | keenstem.com | keenstem.com |
Loriana Lana | Sandrine Dans | TV Presenter | Belgium | LEMONDE.FR | loudbath.com |
Loriana Lana | Honza Dedek | Journalist | Czech Republic | NOVINKY.CZ | thinkablecoal.com |
Loriana Lana | Sam Kerr | Soccer Player | Australia | NEWS.COM.AU | assortedwax.com |
Loriana Lana | David Goffin | Tennis Player | Belgium | LEMONDE.FR | loudbath.com |
Loriana Lana | Ella Kanninen | Journalist | Finland | HS.FI | mushycaptain.com |
Loriana Lana | Natalia Willy Druyts | Singer | Belgium | HLN.BE | neatjellyfish.com |
Loriana Lana | Maria Veitola | Journalist | Finland | HS.FI | regularberet.com |
Loriana Lana | Lucie Bila | Singer and Actress | Czech Republic | IDNES.CZ | thinkablecoal.com |
Loriana Lana | Austalian Residents | Australia | NEWS.AU.COM | assortedwax.com | |
Loriana Lana | Rafał Brzozowski | Singer and TV Presenter | Poland | GAZETA.PL | carefuljail.com |
Loriana Lana | Sigrid Kaag | Deputy Prime Minster | Netherlands | AD.NL | succintmonkey.com |
Loriana Lana | Jens Stoltenberg | Secretary General Of NATO | Norway | AD.NL | succinctmonkey.com |
Loriana Lana | Geert Wilders | Politician | Netherlands | AD.NL | succinctmonkey.com |
Loriana Lana | Karl Nehammr | Austrian Chancellor | Austria | OE24.AT | thirdharmonica.com |
Loriana Lana | Australian Union | Australia | ABC.NET.AU | homelywrist.com | |
Loriana Lana | Giorgia Meloni | Prime Minister | Italy | RAINEWS.IT | educatedtornado.com |
Loriana Lana | Manuel Luís Goucha | Journalist | Portugal | SAPO.PT | keenstem.com |
Loriana Lana | Karan Thapar | Journalist | India | BBC.COM | octtrendi.com |
Sam White | Mikko Kekalainen | Journalist | Finland | HS.FI | regularberet.com |
Sam White | Lucie Bila | Singer and Actress | Czech Republic | IDNES.CZ | rarerice.com |
Sam White | Maria Veitola | Journalist | Finland | HS.FI | mushycaptain.com |
Sam White | Jens Stoltenberg | Secretary General Of NATO | Norway | AD.NL | succintmonkey.com |
Sam White | Geert Wilders | Politician | Netherlands | AD.NL | succintmonkey.com |
Sam White | Sigrid Kaag | Deputy Prime Minster | Netherlands | AD.NL | succintmonkey.com |
Sam White | Karl Nehammr | Austrian Chancellor | Austria | OE24.AT | thirdharmonica.com |
Sam White | Rafał Brzozowski | Singer and TV Presenter | Poland | GAZETA.PL | roundbooklet.com |
Sam White | Anthony Norman Albanese | Prime Minister | Australia | homelywrist.com | homelywrist.com |
Quickmart Kenya | Kriti Sanon | Actress | India | BBC.COM | najosdipco.com |
Quickmart Kenya | Karan Johar | Film maker | India | BBC.COM | najosdipco.com |
Dytrc | Ratan Tata | Industrialist | India | findhiddenwater.com | findhiddenwater.com |
Baatarbileg Yo | Natalia Willy Druyts | Singer | Belgium | HLN.BE | kindlyfeet.com |
Baatarbileg Yo | Tran Thanh | Actor | Vietnam | ENI.COM | educatedtornado.com |
Baatarbileg Yo | Karan Thapar | Journalist | India | BBC.COM | octequiti.com |
Houston Christian University | Paz Padilla | Comedian | Spain | ELTIEMPO.ES | calmmechanic.com |
Houston Christian University | Australian Residents | Australia | 9NEWS.COM.AU | ubiquitousshell.com | |
Houston Christian University | Karl Nehammr | Austrian Chancellor | Austria | OMV.COM | adamantpotato.com |
Houston Christian University | Anthony Norman Albanese | Prime Minister | Australia | ABC.NET.AU | oceaniccourse.com |
Houston Christian University | Anne Glad | Lifestyle Expert | Denmark | BT.DK | miniaturesack.com |
Houston Christian University | Karan Thapar | Journalist | India | BBC.INDIA | curvymedicine.com |
Amaury et Quentin | Australian Residents | Australia | 9NEWS.COM.AU | ubiquitousswitch.com | |
Amaury et Quentin | Anne Glad | Lifestyle Expert | Denmark | BT.DK | miniaturesack.com |
Amaury et Quentin | Karan Thapar | Journalist | India | BBC.IN | foregoingmask.com |
The ad format used by these pages is exactly the same, with many of their ads using the same image, display link, and URL, indicating that these pages are connected to the same network. Some of the international media houses named in these advertisements are as follows:
- BBC – Public broadcaster, London
- Helsingin Sanomat (HS) – Newspaper, Finland
- Gazeta.pl – News portal, Poland
- Het Laatste Nieuws (HLN) – Dutch language newspaper, Belgium
- Radio-télévision belge de la Communauté française (RTBF) – public broadcaster, Belgium
- Nine News (9News) – national news service, Australia.
- Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) – National Broadcaster, Australia
- B.T. – Tabloid, Denmark
- Eltiempo.es – Weather news website, Spain
- Österreich (OE24) – Austrian daily newspaper, Vienna
- Algemeen Dagblad (AD) – Dutch daily Newspaper, Rotterdam
- TV 2 – Government-owned TV channel, Denmark
- Blikk – Newspaper, Hungary
- Le Monde – Newspaper, France
- Novinky.cz – News portal, Czech Republic
- news.com.au – News portal (News Corp Australia)
- iDNES.cz – News portal, Czech Republic
- Rai News 24 – Free-to-air TV channel, Italy
- Sapo – News portal, Portugal
Edited Images Used in Ads
Alt News performed a reverse image search of some of the photographs used in these advertisements, and we noticed that the faces of many journalists and internet personalities had been edited and morphed. Some examples of this are given below.
Sandrine Dans Clarifies Ad is Fake
Belgian TV presenter Sandrine Danes shared a screenshot of the advertisement on her Instagram, calling it fake and clarifying that an edited picture was being circulated. The RTBF domain could also be seen in the preview link of this ad. Ophélie Fontana, a journalist with Belgium’s public broadcaster Radio-télévision belge de la Communauté française (RTBF), said that she had also filed a complaint over the matter. (Source)
Journalist Karan Thapar Calls Out Fake Ad
On November 1, senior Indian journalist Karan Thapar issued a statement on the news portal ‘The Wire’ calling such advertisements fake. He had also filed a complaint with the police on this matter.
Alt News reached out to Karan Thapar for more information. He shared a copy of the complaint lodged with Delhi Police. It contained screenshots of pages named Houston Christian University and Amaury et Quentin. The complaint states that clicking on the posts of these pages opens a replica website called BBC.COM. There is also a fake interview by ‘Sun TV’ featuring Karan Thapar on that website in which a money making scheme was being promoted. Thapar’s team first reported these posts through the Report option on Facebook, upon which the platform did not take any action. Following this, they filed a complaint with Delhi Police. Karan Thapar’s lawyer Munawwar Naseem had informed Facebook’s Grievance Officer about this, after which he was told the content did not violate their community guidelines. Thapar’s lawyer had appealed this to the Grievance Appellate Committee of the Government of India, after which the committee gave an order in favour of the journalist on December 18 and directed Facebook to remove the fake interview. It is worth noting that the two advertisements the Grievance Appellate Committee of the Government of India directed Facebook to delete could still be found on Facebook as posts (1, 2) at the time of writing.
In an article dated November 4 of this year, BBC Hindi described the website running in the name of BBC as fake and had clarified that it had no affiliation to BBC.
Sun TV’s Response
One of the fake websites featured a supposed interview that Thapar gave to ‘Sun TV’. The real outlet also responded to the incident, terming it as fake and denying its involvement in it.
Polish Singer and TV Presenter Rafał Brzozowski’s Image Morphed
Polish news website ‘Show News‘ reported that a photo of Rafał Brzozowski in handcuffs was being shared on social media, but the link was promoting a money-making scheme. When ‘Show News’ contacted Rafał Brzozowski on the matter, he stated that he had never promoted such a platform and the news of his apparent arrest was fake. It was being circulated with a morphed image.
Fake URLs of Media Outlets
The advertisements featuring senior journalists Karan Thapar and Shweta Singh, Indian industrialist Ratan Tata, Indian actress Kriti Sanon, and Karan Johar, host of ‘Koffee with Karan’ along with South African TV presenter Leanne Manas were displayed on impostor pages of BBC, India Today and South African news website News24. Given below are archived links to some of these.
octequiti.com (BBC) – https://archive.is/npYB0
octequiti.com (BBC) – https://archive.is/7jZ6O
octtrendi.com (BBC) – https://archive.is/dRMe2
octshareb.com (BBC) – https://archive.is/HiVUa
octshareb.com (News24) – https://archive.is/JFCWa
octeconi.com (BBC) – https://archive.is/YjJ0c
Thapar was shown promoting money-making schemes on BBC’s impostor website. In an article dated November 4. BBC Hindi issued a statement saying, “We confirm that this is not BBC content, and urge everyone to check links and URLs to ensure they are getting their news from trustworthy sources.”
The ads used the domains of Dutch newspaper Algemeen Dagblad (AD), British media outlet BBC, Australia’s national broadcaster, Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) and Finnish newspaper Helsingin Sanomat (HS) most frequently.
Along with this, the photographs and names of personalities from Australia, India, Belgium, Finland and The Netherlands were used the most in these advertisements.
Among the fake ads being run on Facebook, the photographs and names of Karan Thapar, Polish singer and TV presenter Rafał Brzozowski, Austrian Chancellor Karl Nahmer, Belgian singer Natalia Willy Druyts, and Danish lifestyle expert Annie Glad were used most frequently.
Loophole in Facebook’s Ad Mechanism Not Addressed for Years
In 2016, Canadian hacker Justin Seitz wrote a blog post in which he pointed out a similar loophole in Facebook’s advertising system. In this, he showed how any website could run ads using the URL of any other website through the ‘display link’ present in Facebook’s advertising backend, and how such ads got approved due to a loophole in Facebook’s automation system. He described these types of advertisements as ‘Bait and Switch’. The complete blog post is available here.
How Do These Ads Work?
Alt News posted a demo ad on Facebook on November 14 to test this mechanism. In this ad, we copied the scam websites and placed a link of the news outlet ‘The Wire’, and named it as Alt News in the link preview, so that the people seeing the advertisement would think that it was a link to Alt News, whereas in reality it was a link to ‘The Wire’. We used this article from ‘The Wire’ because the link we have used in the ad is actually a republished article from Alt News.
Meta first flagged our ad saying that the website link in the ad was not included in the preview link or title link. The platform recommended that we verify ownership of the domain to use custom display links in ads. There was also a ‘Request Review’ option.
Our ad was approved within a few minutes of us requesting a review without making any changes to it. This advertisement is still available as a post on Facebook, and an archived link to it can be found here.
This ad, which was live for just a few hours, received over 700 clicks. This demonstrates how running an ad using the name of a media outlet can generate clicks.
This confirmed that Facebook approved the advertisements being run by these pages featuring propaganda in the name of many public figures, using the names and credibility of many international media outlets.
The screenshot below illustrates that when an advertiser creates an ad to run on Facebook, they are asked to provide information related to graphics, URLs, etc. There is also a ‘Display Link’ box present in it. For example, it can be seen how we have included the URL of ‘The Wire’ in our ad, but in the display link we have used the domain of ‘Alt News’, and the name of Alt News is also visible in the preview. Similar to how we ran this ad, many pages run ads using this loophole to promote scam websites using the names of famous personalities and the credibility of international media outlets.
Facebook’s Stance on the Matter
In 2017, Forbes published a report citing a blog by Canadian hacker Justin Seitz that exposed a loophole in Facebook’s advertising system. In it, the outlet interviewed Seitz and also quoted a Facebook spokesperson on this. Facebook’s then-spokesman Tom Channick defended the option to edit the URL, saying, “The use of this option is not always deceptive or malicious.” He said, for example, when a non-profit organisation was running a donation drive using Facebook ads through a third-party site, it may want to have its domain name appear in the ad. The website’s domain may appear to be a link to an advertisement running through a third-party site. Channick, speaking to Forbes, defended the option to display links in Facebook ads, saying that it was not always an unexpected or confusing experience for a user.
Responding to Facebook’s statement, Seitz said that allowing differences in display URLs and landing pages was a terrible idea. He disagreed with Facebook’s argument, which cited an example of a hypothetical non-profit organisation, saying any organisation could easily create a landing page on its website that would direct users to the donation site.
We informed Facebook about such an advertisement on November 4, 2023 and sent them some questions related to it, but we have not received any response from them. Besides, the advertisement which we flagged to the platform in an email is still live following the publication of this article, and can be accessed here.
Independent journalism that speaks truth to power and is free of corporate and political control is possible only when people start contributing towards the same. Please consider donating towards this endeavour to fight fake news and misinformation.