JNU student Umar Khalid was allegedly attacked in the afternoon of August 13 in Delhi outside Constitution Club near Parliament. Initial reports said that an unidentified assailant targeted Khalid who managed to escape unhurt.

Investigations are underway, however, Opindia, MyNation and Postcard News, playing jury to the incident, expeditiously gave the verdict that Khalid was “not present at the spot when the shot was fired”. 

Their reportage was based on the statements of an “eyewitness” Santosh Kumar to ABP journalist Vikas Bhaoduria. Describing his version of events, Kumar claimed that “Umar Khalid wasn’t present during the firing and came out from inside the Constitution Club later”. The testimony given by Kumar, who is a journalist with Dainik Bhaskar, is widespread on social media.

Alt News contacted Umar Khalid to ascertain his version of events. He said, “The incident happened next to a tea stall outside the Constitution Club. When we started leaving, a guy came from behind, held my neck and overpowered me. I fell down in the mud. He took out a pistol and started aiming at me. My instinctive reaction was not to let him aim and hold his hand away. My friends also started resisting and pushed him aside. He then ran from the spot.” 

After Santosh Kumar claimed in a video testimony that Khalid was not present at the scene of firing, he put out another statement, altering his version of events. “I don’t know if the man who fell down was Umar or not,” he tweeted.

This clarification had been conveniently omitted by OpindiaMyNation and Postcard News.

The headline of the Opindia article reads – “As ‘Liberals’ blame Arnab Goswami, eyewitness claims Umar Khalid wasn’t even present at alleged firing site”. 

Opindia tweeted their article twice – the first time at 3:44 PM (Kumar’s testimony was tweeted by Bhaoduria at 3:34 PM); and the second time at 4:28 PM. Kumar also happened to tweet his altered statement at 4:28 PM, thus it is understandable if Opindia missed including his flip-flop. However, it took them nearly four hours to add Kumar’s altered statement, without the same reflecting in the title of their article.

MyNation and Postcard News follow Opindia’s footsteps 

Soon after Opindia’s selective reporting, MyNation published an article titled – “Umar Khalid was not even at spot when shot was fired: Eyewitness punctures narrative.” Their article was published at 5:30 PM, a good one hour after Kumar’s clarification, yet MyNation conveniently left it out.

Editor of MyNation, Abhijit Majumder also tweeted the article without Kumar’s revised statement.

Postcard News wasn’t far behind and published an article attacking senior journalist Barkha Dutt. They too have omitted Kumar’s changed testimony.

Delhi Police has registered a case under Section 307 of the Arms Act against unknown persons. The cops reportedly have clues and say that the culprits would soon be arrested.

In the matter of a few hours, a journalist published an unverified witness testimony on a public platform, which was altered an hour later by the same journalist who gave the original testimony, yet his dubious claim was picked up by multiple journalists who jumped the gun to declare that Khalid was not attacked. Among them was AFP’s Bhuvan Bagga, Swaraj Magazine’s Swati Goel Sharma and Aditya Chaudhary. Ironically, most of their tweets came post Kumar’s altered testimony.

Santosh Kumar’s “witness testimony” has nearly 25,000 views and over 3,000 shares only from Twitter. Contrastingly, his “clarification” has only 184 retweets. Since reports of the attack began pouring in, social media was brimming with tweets attempting to discredit Khalid’s claims. Selective reportage by Opindia, MyNation and Postcard News added to the tumultuous situation thus, fanning the misinformation ecosystem.

Donate to Alt News!
Independent journalism that speaks truth to power and is free of corporate and political control is possible only when people start contributing towards the same. Please consider donating towards this endeavour to fight fake news and misinformation.

To make an instant donation, click on the "Donate Now" button above. For information regarding donation via Bank Transfer/Cheque/DD, click here.
You could follow Alt News posts either via our Facebook page or by following us on Twitter or by subscribing to our E-mail updates.


8
Leave a Reply

avatar
2 Comment threads
6 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
Tarun BajpaiAwanish SharmaguestRakesh Agrawal Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Awanish Sharma
Guest
Awanish Sharma

I heard his comment on one of the PAID MEDIA NDTV, where he says he caught the hand of attacker which was having gun and in another second he says he couldn’t see his face because he was attacked from behind, abey chutiyea if someone wanted to shoot you from behind how you would have caught his hand and didn’t see his face, this is another media masala by paid media like NDTV ALT NEWS, bloody fakers

Rakesh Agrawal
Guest
Rakesh Agrawal

Mr. Bhakt, open your eyes and put some sentiment in your soul-less brain, else someone like that shit-pot who tried to shoot Khalid will one day shoot you or someone dear to you!

Awanish Sharma
Guest
Awanish Sharma

Mr Lauda Sucker suck something else it will help in your brain growth, we know you people paid for all this shit….

Tarun Bajpai
Guest
Tarun Bajpai

mjhe samajh nahi ata har koi dissenting opinion wala paid hai…bhai mjhe batao zara ..ye itne sare paise a kaha se rahe hai….pakistan se paise lene ke itne arop lagte hai logo pe …zara socha hai pakistan ki aukat ke bare me?…kya uski itni haisiyat hai? har kisi ko paise bant ta phire….had hai yaar bade ho jao sharma ji

guest
Guest
guest

Mr. NDTV version and Yakub Menon supporter. sorry we dont have sentiment for Bharart ke tukde..Tujhe bhi Umar ki tarah Azadi chahiye to Burwan wali Azadi denge…Tu to naam badal kar comment kar rha hai.. Itni bhi aukat nhi thi..apane asli naam se comment kar…

Tarun Bajpai
Guest
Tarun Bajpai

bhai kam padhe likhe ho.kyn mu kholte ho..aur jab kholte ho to hug dete ho….Umar ki azadi aur burhan ki azadi me fark hai..har issue ko religion aur nationalism ke naam pe dekhte ho…apna dimag lagane pe insult feel karte ho?…..powerfull mind dont generalise…it tries to find the real facts…hope you get wisdom some day…jo bhi tmhare views se disagree karta hai wo pakistani hai ya antinational hai…..wahhhh …socho bhai kabhi is hasne wali baat pe

Rakesh Agrawal
Guest
Rakesh Agrawal

Bloody, sanghi shit is postcard news! Paid & bikau chamacha of Modi & Shah! Throw shit on its face and expose the barrage of lies it perpetuates!

guest
Guest
guest

How much frustation you have it is clear from your abusive words…ha ha ha..Tu bakta rah..kuchh nhi hoga….