A claim about a Hindu boy’s throat being slit by a sword during a Muharram procession in Gauri Bazar area of Deoria district in Uttar Pradesh is circulating on social media.“देवरिया के गौरीबाजार थानाक्षेत्र में इस्लामिक आतंकियों ने मुहर्रम के जुलूस की आड़ में अल्पवयस्क हिन्दू लड़के विशाल ओझा का तलवार से गला काटा , यक्ष प्रश्न ये है की आरोपी इस्लामिक आतंकी अब तक गिरफ्तार क्यों नहीं हुए ? @deoriapolice @Uppolice (In Deoria’s Gauri Bazaar, Islamic terrorists in a Muharram procession slit Hindu boy Vishal Ojha’s throat. The question is why havent the Islamic terrorists been arrested yet? (translation)” tweeted a social media user, Ashutosh Snehsagar on September 21, 2018.
Along with the message, he has tweeted a video of a boy bleeding profusely. The video was originally posted by Breaking Tube, a twitter handle.
Another Twitter user Pooja Singh shared an article by Breaking Tube which said, “Vishal Ojha, a class 6th student’s throat was slit by a pissful during #Muharram celebration in Deoria. His condition is critical now. By slitting the throats of Kafirs these people celebrate their festivals. Still festivals of Hindus are dangerous.” Several other individual user have also tweeted the claim that the boy was hurt by sword (1,2,3,4).
The article published by Breaking Tube which we found to be the source of this claim interestingly contains a contradictory police statement saying, “…On this matter, police said that Vishal was injured by a tubelight explosion.”
Dainik Bharat, a fake news website also wrote an article with a communal narrative.
Clarification by Deoria police
In a statement given to Alt News, Circle Officer Varun Mishra of Deoria Police clarified, “Amar Ujala has misreported. We had also tweeted the details about the incident. His principal who was also present at the spot said he was injured in a tubelight explosion. It was unintentional and an accident.” When Alt News spoke to District Magistrate Amit Kishore, he also corroborated that the boy was injured in a tubelight explosion.
Deoria police has tweeted on September 21 that the boy seen in the video, Vishal Ojha had been injured after tubelight shards had slit his throat during a Muharram procession.
— DEORIA POLICE (@deoriapolice) September 21, 2018
The video posted below is illustrative, and shows young men playing with tubelights and shattering them on each other.
Misreporting by media organisations
It stated, “At around 6:30 in the evening during a swordplay, a sword wielded by a young man slashed vishal’s throat, who was standing across the street. -translated”. Incidentally, Amar Ujala in its article did not report the statement by Deoria police.
Patrika also reported that his throat was slit by a sword with a conflicting statement from the DM.
The reportage of Eenadu India also stated the same claim based on the accounts of local residents with a differing police statement.
News18 was also among those who misreported that the boy’s throat was slit by a sword.
देवरिया- धारधार हथियार से छात्र का गला काटा. गम्भीर हालत में अस्पताल में भर्ती. मोहर्रम का जुलूस देखने गया था छात्र. गौरीबाजार थाना क्षेत्र के लँगड़ी चौराहे का मामला. क्षेत्र में तनाव की स्थिति. आक्रोशित लोगों ने सड़क को किया जाम. भारी पुलिस बल तैनात.
— News18 Uttar Pradesh (@News18UP) September 21, 2018
Social media users often endorse, wittingly or otherwise, hateful narratives woven around incidents which are sometimes exacerbated through misreporting by media organisations. An accident was sought to be communalised through a dubious portal like Breaking Tube and subsequently by certain users. Such attempts to vitiate inter-communal harmony are observed on social media time and again.
Independent journalism that speaks truth to power and is free of corporate and political control is possible only when people start contributing towards the same. Please consider donating towards this endeavour to fight fake news and misinformation.