“A******s of Thornton Reuters here is a lady who is ‘allowed’ 3 sips of water before being stoned to death. How safe is she, according to you ?” An image is currently viral on social media with the aforementioned text, many of them misspelling “Thomson Reuters” as “Thornton Reuters”. This is in the aftermath of Thomson Reuters releasing a report which ranks India as the most dangerous country for women. In this particular image, a woman can be seen sipping water off a spoon with only her head above the ground and the rest of her body buried under. This image was shared by Gita Kapoor who is followed by PM Modi on Twitter. Alt News has documented multiple instances where Gita Kapoor has shared misleading information (1, 2, 3).
A******s of Thornton Reuters here is a lady who is ‘allowed’ 3 sips of water before being stoned to death. How safe is she, according to you ? pic.twitter.com/Kaiuu8xM4c
— Gita S. Kapoor (@GitaSKapoor) June 28, 2018
Madhu Kishwar, who frequently shares misleading posts on her Twitter timeline, also retweeted Gita Kapoor’s tweet while attacking activists and journalists.
Certainly safer than hapless Rana Ayyub, Indira Jaisingh, Teesta Setalvad, Vrinda Grover, Kavita Krishnan, Priyanka Chaturvedi & all the leftist women & women of Rahul Brigade living in wretched India! https://t.co/dT4lijbxA4
— MadhuPurnima Kishwar (@madhukishwar) June 28, 2018
This has been shared multiple times on Facebook with the identical message including the spelling error.
Over a period of time, the same image has been used on multiple websites with similar claims, the most common being ‘Iranian woman stoned to death’.
A Twitter user Sarthak Ray dug into the origins of the image that is being circulated and found that it is actually from Colombia and is part of a protest.
Links to the original photos.
Deliberately spreading fake stuff as fact
— Sarthak Ray (@RAYsarthak) June 29, 2018
An image of the same woman, who is claimed to have been stoned, is available as part of stock photos on the Adobe website along with the following description:
“Colombian Maria Gabriela Ruiz, 66, (C) is aided by a woman while she lies buried in the ground up to her neck along with Olmedo Gomez, 42,(bottom) and Nicolas Salazar, 32, during a protest in a popular sector of Cali, July 4, 2003. Three people, two men and a woman, buried themselves three days ago in protest against the government because 150 displaced persons have not been relocated to a safe sector of Cali.”
Yet another close-up image of Ruiz is available on Getty images, an American stock photo agency that supplies licensed images to businesses, creative professionals and the media.
False claims on social media are frequently used to create and support certain political narratives. The report listing India as the most dangerous country for women has invited mixed reactions. While there are those who see merit in it, others are skeptical. Notwithstanding the merits and demerits of the report and the arguments surrounding it, this was yet another case where misinformation was used to support a desired narrative.
Independent journalism that speaks truth to power and is free of corporate and political control is possible only when people start contributing towards the same. Please consider donating towards this endeavour to fight fake news and misinformation.