For the advancement of right-wing forces in Bengal, there’s been a continuous and deliberate attempt to spread fake images/videos to project that Bengal is being taken over by Muslims. Recently, we wrote about how the killing of one Abu Syed in Bangladesh was portrayed as a Hindu man being killed by Muslims in Bengal. The aggressive Hindutva posturing during this year’s Ram Navmi celebrations in Bengal with sword waving, slogans and overall provocative behaviour was also a strategy to further the polarisation of voters. There are increasing instances of small-scale communal disturbances in Bengal. The target seems to be 2019 elections and the preparations have begun well in advance.
As part of the preparations, now there’s a new video which has gone viral on social media which claims that a Hindu man was beaten up on Hanuman Jayanti (April 11th, 2017) by 2 Muslim IPS officers. We first noticed this video on the right-wing website PostCard.news. They posted an article with the title, “Watch!! Is Birbhum a part of Pakistan or Bangladesh?” in which they claim that a Hindu man was beaten up by two Muslim IPS officers on Hanuman Jayanti. The first two paras in the article narrate their version of the story and are quoted below.
Jihadi Didi’s West Bengal is a safe haven for all Islamic Fanatics. Momota first tried to halt Ram Navami celebrations. Even after the High court stayed the Ram Navami celebrations, Momota had evil plans for Hanuman Jayanti. The devotees of Birbhum district were seen getting trashed by WB police on the instructions of Jihadi Didi. Their only mistake was that they decided to undertake a peaceful procession during the festival of Hanuman Jayanti.
The police officers had been instructed to trash the ‘Kafirs.’ This happened in the Birbhum district of West Bengal. For once, you may think that this is Pakistan or Bangladesh. But, no this is India’s very own Jihad land. The 2 IPS Muslim officers did not think twice before mercilessly bashing the Hanuman devotees. The Devotee can be heard saying “Jai Bajrangbali” even after being lati-charged by the police.
At the bottom of PostCard article is a video clip which shows a man being thrashed by a police personnel while several constables watch. We captured the article on their website and the video in the following YouTube video.
We tracked down this particular video to check its authenticity. As it turns out, the video is neither of Hanuman Jayanti which was celebrated on April 11, 2017 nor was the incident of police brutality from Bengal. This video has been available on Youtube for close to 3 years now and has been uploaded multiple times using various titles. The first instance that we could find was uploaded on September 30, 2014.
Following are the few instances of this video available on Youtube. The latest in the series claims that his incident happened in Uttar Pradesh. Clearly, the same video is being re-circulated with misleading titles and the origin of the video is unknown.
Posted on September 30, 2014 – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IoRodq_DN68
Posted on April 7, 2015 – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yGAdKz3A2I
Posted on June 27, 2016 – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x0mEQymlpsU
This video is currently viral on Facebook/WhatsApp and has been shared by multiple pages/individual profiles. Here is a non-exhaustive list of pages/profiles which have shared it with the misleading story of a Hindu man being beaten up by Muslim IPS officers and has been watched by lakhs of people on different mediums.
Hindu Jwala – https://www.facebook.com/HinduJwalaE/videos/1907119226224279/
Indian Politics – https://www.facebook.com/Indiandemocracy/videos/787854418059613/
We Support RSS – https://www.facebook.com/sanghmantra/videos/1448519551881691/
Let’s Expose Paid Media – https://www.facebook.com/812524912185155/videos/1103271256443851/
We Support Rohit Sardana –https://www.facebook.com/ZeeNewsRohitSardana/videos/480554009002351/
Atal Bihari Vajpayee – https://www.facebook.com/greatatal/videos/1453468894711587/
RSS – Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh Fans – https://www.facebook.com/RSS.Fan.Page/videos/1464952306900183/
Divyesh Parikh – https://www.facebook.com/dinesh.parikh/videos/10155377258584273/
Chetan P Shetty – https://www.facebook.com/chethanp.shetty/posts/1234503543325125
But who came up with this fake story originally? It turns out that it was Asansol District’s BJP IT Cell in-charge Tarun Sengupta who originally posted this on his Facebook timeline at 8:47 pm on April 17th. We also captured Mr Tarun Gupta’s little mischief on a video just in case if he suddenly develops amnesia.
According to Tarun Sengupta’s Twitter profile, he is the BJP Asansol District IT Incharge.
The same profile picture that is used on the Twitter profile is also available on Tarun Sengupta’s Facebook profile from which the fake video was posted thus proving that the Facebook profile and Twitter profile belong to the same person.
In fact, Tarun Sengupta seems quite close to BJP top brass in Bengal including BJP MP Babul Supriyo. According to pictures on Tarun Sengupta’s profile, his family had attended the celebrations of BJP MP Babul Supriyo’s swearing in. A picture of Tarun Sengupta’s son can be seen with BJP State Executive Member from Bengal, Nirmal Karmakar (circled).
We at Alt News believe that these fake videos which do the rounds on social media and WhatsApp are being created in an organised and pre-planned manner. This is yet another proof that people officially in BJP are also a part of this dangerous propaganda of injecting communal poison in the society. Will BJP now disown Tarun Sengupta just the way they disowned the alleged ISI agents from BJP’s IT cell in Bhopal?
Here’s a list of some other videos that we at Alt News have debunked in the past couple months.
- A Bangladeshi video is being trended as a Hindu being killed by Muslims in Nawada, Bihar
- Killing of one Abu Syed in Bangladesh shared 37000+ times on FB as a Hindu killed by Muslims in West Bengal
- Right-wingers pass off a Guatemalan mob lynching video as one of a Marwadi woman being burnt alive by a Muslim mob
- BJP Supporters are passing off a Mexican stabbing video as one of RSS member getting killed in Kerala
- How the sick right wing machinery is circulating a fake video claiming it is Gurmehar Kaur drinking and dancing