A video of a man vandalising a statue is viral on social media with the claim that he is a Muslim migrant in Italy who opposed the nakedness of the statue.
A muslim migrant destroying a statue in Italy , b’cos part of the body is showing. Europe does not know what is coming their way in next 5 to 15 years..👇🏿 pic.twitter.com/Rzv7XFrpnf
— Reema Sahani (@reema_sahanii) June 11, 2021
[Complete message in Hindi: एक मुस्लिम शरणार्थी इटली में एक मूर्ति को नष्ट कर रहा है, स्पष्ट दिखा रहा है वो एक शांतिदूत हैं शायद यूरोप को नहीं पता कि अगले 5-10 वर्षों में उनके साथ क्या क्या घटने वाला है भारत को सतर्क रहते हुए जल्द से जल्द अवैध बांग्लादेशियों और रोहिंग्या को निकलना चाहिए #इसलिए_nrc_चाहिए]
The video has been circulating on Twitter and Facebook since May 2019.
A Muslim migrant destroying a statue in Italy, b’cos parts of a Women body is exposed. Europe does not know what is coming their way in next 5 to 15 years. They used to give lessons to India on human rights and minority respect, tolerance and so on ..now they will know !!!! pic.twitter.com/5vTcUaTjM7
— MAJOR SUBRAT MISHRA,SM 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 (@SUBRATSMSM) May 4, 2019
Video from Algeria
A simple keyword search on Google took us to multiple reports related to the incident. According to Step Feed, a MENA-focused news organisation, the incident took place in Algeria in 2017. A Salafist extremist was arrested by the Algerian authorities for vandalising the statue of Ain El Fouara in Setif, Algeria. Daily Mail too reported on the incident, along with the before and after photos of the statue. While Step Feed says the man arrested was a religious fundamentalist, Daily Mail wrote that he was suffering from mental illness.
— Ennahar Tv النهار (@ennaharonline) December 18, 2017
Step Feed also reported that Azzedine Mihoubi, who was the Minister of Culture at that time, spoke in an Egyptian TV program called “DMC evening”, confirming that the motive behind the attack was religious. He further added that the statue was built 120 years ago and bears a significant cultural value in Algeria and a number of experts were deployed to restore the statue.
In 2018, AP reported a similar incident of a man destroying the statue in Setif, Algeria. The report says that Setif Communications Director Mohamed Touiri said that a Salafist disfigured the face, breasts and arm of the statue. It further adds that Culture Minister Azzedine Mihoubi suggested in a tweet that the culprit was the same man who damaged the statue in 2017.
مرة أخرى، تمتد يد التخريب لتمثال عين الفوارة، حيث تمكّن مواطنون من إيقاف شخص حاول تدمير التمثال الذي يتوسط مدينة سطيف. وقد تعرفت مصالح الأمن على هوية الجاني، وهو مسبوق قضائيا ويعاني من اضطرابات عقلية.
التمثال أصيب بأضرار خفيفة، ستتم معالجتها. وإننا لنهيب بتدخل المواطنين السريع. pic.twitter.com/e4Nnq31eC0
— azzedine mihoubi (@azzedinemihoub3) October 9, 2018
According to France24, the Ain El Fouara statue (“the fountain’s source” in English) is a work of French sculptor Francis de Saint-Vidal. It was unveiled in 1898 and has since become a symbolic monument in the town, where it is popular among the locals. Over the years the nakedness of the female figure has caused multiple controversies. On April 22, 1997, it was damaged by a homemade bomb. It was also attacked by a man with a hammer on February 28, 2006. The statue was repaired after each attack.
We have compared a screengrab showing the statue in the video with a publically available photograph of the statue. As evident, it is the same structure in Setif, Algeria.
Thus a video of a man vandalising a statue in Algeria has been falsely shared as a Muslim migrant destroying the structure in Italy. There are contradictory reports on the motive behind the act. While some say it was religious, others claim that the perpetrator was mentally unstable.
Independent journalism that speaks truth to power and is free of corporate and political control is possible only when people contribute towards the same. Please consider donating in support of this endeavour to fight misinformation and disinformation.
To make an instant donation, click on the "Donate Now" button above. For information regarding donation via Bank Transfer/Cheque/DD, click here.